Co-organisers Sponsors

Judging Criteria

Part 1 Duration of Delivery  

 
Duration
Order
Preliminaries
Quarter-Final
Semi-Final
Grand Final
Captain of aff.
2min30s
3min
3min
3min
Captain of opp
2min30s
3min
3min
3min
1st speaker of aff.
2min30s
3min
3min
3min
1st speaker of opp.
2min30s
3min
3min
3min
2nd speaker of aff.
2min30s
3min
3min
3min
2nd speaker of opp.
2min30s
3min
3min
3min
Interrogative Debating session (*):
Preparation of Questioning、
Questioning、
Preparation of Answering、
Answering


15s
20s
15s
40s


15s
20s
15s
40s
-----
-----
Floor Time(**)
-----
-----
-----
12min
Free Debate (***)
-----
-----
4min (each team)
4min (each team)
Preparation of summary
1min
1min
1min
1min
Captain summary of opp.
3min30s
4min
4min
5min
Captain summary of aff.
3min30s
4min
4min
5min

(*)
The arrangement of Interrogative Debating session at Preliminaries and the Quarter-Final is as follows:
1. 2nd speaker of affirmative starts to ask a question to 2nd speaker of opposition
2. 2nd speaker of opposition replies the question, and asks a question to 1st speaker of affirmative
3. 1st speaker of affirmative replies the question, and asks a question to 1st speaker of opposition
4. 1st speaker of opposition replies the question, and asks a question to captain of affirmative
5. Captain of affirmative replies the question, and asks a question to captain of opposition
6. Captain of opposition replies the question, and asks a question to 2nd speaker of affirmative, 2nd speaker of affirmative replies finally.
The individual with the highest average score in the Interrogative Debating session will be awarded as the " Best Interrogative Debater". If more than one debaters gain the same score, final voting will be held among the adjudicators.
(**)
There will be a Floor Time in Grand Final. The affirmative and opposition teams will take turns to answer 3 floor questionings from each debating school. The duration of each question and answer will be 1 minute respectively. There is no limit of questions that the floor speaker can ask within the time, however, he/she cannot designate any debater to answer the questions.
(***)
In Free Debate session, each team will be given a total of 4 minutes in delivering their speech. Speakers will be given a maximum of 10-second preparation time for each speech before the delivery. It is the choice of a speaker whether to consume the total 10 seconds each time. The 10-second preparation time will be counted separately from the 4-minute free debate time. Time keeper will ring the bell once to start the 10-second preparation right after the speaker has delivered his/her speech. When the 10-second preparation time ends, time keeper will ring once and the speaker of the opponent team should start to deliver the speech. Once the 10-second preparation time end and the bell rings, the time keeper will start and continue counting down the 4-minute free debate time whether the speaker is delivering the speech or not.

When the delivery time accumulates to 3 mins 30 seconds, the timekeeper will ring the bell once and a “30 seconds left sign” will be displayed on and off stage as reminder; and the speaker must continue his/her speech until using up the remaining time (change of speaker is prohibited). Otherwise, it will be considered as forfeiting the remaining time.

When either one team uses up its 4 minutes timeslot, the other team should continue to use up its remaining time by one speaker (change of speaker is prohibited). If the team chooses not to use up its remaining time, the team has to notify the chairperson.

The affirmative team will start the Free Debate followed by the opposition team. Each team can use the 4 minutes by separating them into several speeches. However, only one debater is allowed to deliver his/her speech at one time. Each individual speaker is obliged to participate during the free debate session. Non-participation of a single speaker means a reduction of 10 points out of the team’s total score.

There is no grace period in the Free Debate session. Speaker must end his or her speech after the bell rang. Otherwise, the adjudicators reserve the right to deduct the marks.


Timekeeping
Competition
Debater
Delivery Time
Start
Last 30 seconds
End
Grace Period 15 seconds
The 16th second to the 20th second
After the 20th second
Preliminaries
Captain of aff.
Captain of opp.
1st speaker of aff.
1st speaker of opp.
2nd speaker of aff.
2nd speaker of opp.
2min30s
0s
(Ring bell once)
2min
(Ring bell once)
2min30s
(Ring bell twice)
2min31s - 2min45s
2min46s (Ring bell five times and deduct 5pts)*
Speaker must
end his/her
speech and
return to the
seat
Interrogative Debating session(#)
9min in total, time allocation is as follows:
Preparation of Questioning (15s)
Questioning (20s)
Preparation of Answering (15s)
Answering (40s)
Preparation of summary
1min
Summary from opp. captain
Summary from aff. captain
3min30s
0s
(Ring bell once)
3min
(Ring bell once)
3min30s
(Ring bell twice)
3min31s -
3min45s
3min46s (Ring bell five times and deduct 5pts)*
Quarter-Final
Captain of aff.
Captain of opp.
1st speaker of aff.
1st speaker of opp.
2nd speaker of aff.
2nd speaker of opp.
3min
0s
(Ring bell once)
2min30s
(Ring bell once)
3min
(Ring bell twice)
3min01s -
3min15s
3min16s (Ring bell five times and deduct 5pts)*
Speaker must
end his/her
speech and
return to the
seat
Interrogative Debating session(#)
9min in total, time allocation is as follows:
Preparation of Questioning (15s)
Questioning (20s)
Preparation of Answering (15s)
Answering (40s)
Preparation of summary
1min
Summary from opp. captain
Summary from aff. captain
4min
0s
(Ring bell once)
3min30s
(Ring bell once)
4min
(Ring bell twice)
4min01s -
4min15s
4min16s (Ring bell five times and deduct 5pts)*
Semi-Final
Captain of aff.
Captain of opp.
1st speaker of aff.
1st speaker of opp.
2nd speaker of aff.
2nd speaker of opp.
3min
0s
(Ring bell once)
2min30s
(Ring bell once)
3min
(Ring bell twice)
3min01s -
3min15s
3min16s (Ring bell five times and deduct 5pts)*
Speaker must
end his/her
speech and
return to the
seat
Free Debate
4min
0s
(Ring bell once)
3min30s
(Ring bell once)
4min
(Ring bell twice)
-----
-----
10 sec maximum preparation time for each speech
(Ring bell once to start; Ring bell once after 10s)
Preparation of summary
1min
Summary from opp. captain
Summary from aff. captain
4min
0s
(Ring bell once)
3min30s
(Ring bell once)
4min
(Ring bell twice)
4min01s -
4min15s
4min16s (Ring bell five times and deduct 5pts)*
Grand Final
Captain of aff.
Captain of opp.
1st speaker of aff.
1st speaker of opp.
2nd speaker of aff.
2nd speaker of opp.
3min
0s
(Ring bell once)
2min30s
(Ring bell once)
3min
(Ring bell twice)
3min01s -
3min15s
3min16s (Ring bell five times and deduct 5pts)*
Speaker must
end his/her
speech and
return to the
seat
Floor Time
1min
0s
(Ring bell once)
45s
(Ring bell once)
1min
(Ring bell twice)
-----
-----
Free Debate
4min
0s
(Ring bell once)
3min30s
(Ring bell once)
4min
(Ring bell twice)
-----
-----
10 sec maximum preparation time for each speech
(Ring bell once to start; Ring bell once after 10s)
Preparation of summary
1min
Summary from opp. captain
Summary from aff. captain
5min
0s
(Ring bell once)
4min30s
(Ring bell once)
5min
(Ring bell twice)
5min01s -
5min15s
5min16s (Ring bell five times and deduct 5pts)*
* Deduct 5 points from each adjudicator's total score.
(#) Interrogative Debating session
1) All debaters must follow the pre-set order in delivering speech, or no marks will be given to the debater in the designated section
2) There is no grace period in the Interrogative Debating session. Speaker must follow the pre-set flow and must end his or her speech after the bell rang. Otherwise, the adjudicators reserve the right to deduct the marks.
Notes
Aff. : Affirmative team
Opp. : Opposition team